Watson Microsystem 70 Microscope.

A review.


By Ian Walker. UK.


Introduction.

The Watson Microsystem 70 microscope was introduced in the mid 1960's, it is a modular design with many options, coming in several variations of stand from basic none Kohler 'student' all the way up to the Hilux 70 with substantial 100 watt external halogen illumination and automatic exposure camera system designed for serious laboratory work. In this review I consider whether Watson have carried over 100 years of mechanical and optical expertise into a well designed microscope or whether compromises have been made and costs cut to allow sales in an ever more crowded environment with models from Zeiss, Leitz et al of the same period.

These microscopes come up quite frequently on eBay and the great thing is they are usually cheap, in the order of 120 to 200, this one cost 132 and will typically buy you a specification similar to the one shown below making it a possible choice on a short list for anyone starting out in microscopy with the student models or experienced user who wants to add another stand with the better specified System 70's or Hilux 70, the latter will more likely to attract higher prices however.

The model here is middle of the range with a 30 watt lamp, Kohler illumination, well corrected 'dual disk' achromatic NA 0.90 dry phase condenser, 4 objective turret [excellent feel on rotation] with 3 phase objectives and binocular head with 1.5x magnification. The typical student model would be a monocular and simple illumination whilst the top of the range a much more bulky affair, typical examples are shown from copies of the original literature a bit later...




Typical Watson System 70 phase microscope.

Above, Watson Microsystem 70 microscope with phase option bought by the author, notice the large thumb wheel sub stage height control, which Watson note is designed to be used with the two thumbs while the fingers are on the coarse / fine focus. This works smoothly but personally prefer the more conventional knob design acting on a rack and pinion. There are receptacles for phase telescope etc placed within the large metal enclosure housing the power supply, the latter can be removed independently however. The deep base makes the binocular head quite high off the table and I needed a cushion on the chair to bring me to the right height for comfortable viewing.




Hilux 70 with 100 watt halogen lighting and camera options.

(Source: Little Imp CD 'Watson Microsystem 70 Photographic Equipment' brochure.)

Watson Hilux 70 fitted with additional base housing the 100 watt illumination with typical camera attachment [7 different bodies were available] together with automated exposure system using the accessories shown. The size and weight would place it along side the larger stands from Zeiss and Leitz of the same period such as the Zeiss Photomicroscope series.




Student version of the Watson Microsystem 70.

(Source: Little Imp CD 'A Handbook for Watson Microsystem 70' brochure.)

Clean lines of the monocular version of the System 70 fitted with Abbe condenser [option of adding simple phase attachments], the mechanical stage along side many other options would bring it up to a better specified stand. The basic components like limb and focus block are the same throughout the complete range. Note the monocular head is supplied with an external securing screw, this was not fitted on my stand. The none Kohler lighting base would limit the practicality for more serious work but even the bases are interchangeable in the System 70 so you could upgrade to Kohler. The 'flip-down' hand supports shown here were missing on my stand.


The Watson literature relates to a number of innovations in the design and that components have been 'life tested' for durability with wear compensation in key areas like the main focus block, this is born out with the latter with excellent feel being not too stiff and of a 'fluid action', it is a pleasure to use with zero play using the 90x oil immersion objective after no doubt many hard years being used in the laboratory.

The coarse focus uses principles based on many years of improvements in this area and is user adjustable for tension whilst the fine focus is achieved by "twin beryllium copper spring parallelogram with no sliding parts giving a rigid hysteresis free movement".




Details from the Watson illustrated guide showing schematics of parts.

(Source: Little Imp CD 'Watson Microsystem 70 Illustrated Guide' brochure.)

The above picture is from the sales brochure giving details of some of the parts like the removable focus block and cam mechanism used in the sub stage height control. Rather than rack and pinion which is almost universally adopted in research microscopes Watson came up with a space saving rotary control. I don't like it although I guess, as always, it is down to personal preference.



Overview.

The heavy [boxed weight 14Kg] Kohler microscope comes in a sturdy but light weight tall wooden box [approx 7x11x20 inches w.d.h] with carry handle shown below, this houses the stand and removable power supply which rests on the back of the limb by gravity and a large locating pin fits in the respective hole in the back of the limb, this makes for a neat system with relatively small footprint. The Kohler illumination is housed in a substantial base whilst the bottom panel can easily be removed for maintenance, two points on the base accept the lever operated catches housed on the bottom edge on the front and rear of the lid. Paintwork of the microscope is 'battleship grey' and well finished being smooth and silky.

The binocular head is of compact design and can be rotated but not easily removed as there is no thumb screw rather a recessed Allen bolt. No dust can enter at any point when the binocular head is in situ as all the optics are well shrouded and the inter-ocular distance easily set by pulling each end of the slide, calibrations are provided as usual. The stage which appears to be vulcanite or similar can either be 'plain' with plastic stage clips, a retrofit attachable slide carrier fixed with 3 Allen bolts or stage with integrated concentric X Y drop down type. The field iris is housed in the base similar to some of the later Leitz models.



Neat case with handle.

A slim well made case makes for a neat appearance, you can imagine many of these sat side by side along laboratory benches in the mornings ready for all the students to arrive, quick release catches makes handling straightforward although caution must be used pulling the case clear not to snag on any parts of the microscope. This one is labeled No.81 so part of a large consignment.

Sub stage components.



Detail of under stage.

The above photograph shows a close up of the under stage and base, the large field lens which can house square colour or polar filters easily comes off on locating pins which for transport by post makes it a necessity to tape it down or remove and pack, this one wasn't and could have caused much damage in transit to objectives or paintwork, thankfully it didn't! The lever on the left of the base actuates a swing in auxiliary lens for the Kohler system for objectives 20x - 100x. The knob on the right of the base actuates the field diaphragm similar to some Leitz and Leica designs. A centering sub stage houses the condenser, note the two rings on the condenser, the top is for all dry objectives, the bottom for oil immersion. It is unusual and unlike Zeiss in that the condenser iris is still in the light path at all times and must be adjusted to suit for phase operation. There are 'blank' positions in upper and lower disks to allow for correct setting for each objective range. Just below the centering screws there is the rather narrow condenser diaphragm control, although large in diameter I found this not as convenient as those with a long arm, the latter easier to adjust and grip, especially when the control is partly hidden in normal operation. The slots at the edge of the base are to accept hand rests which are missing on this stand.

Note the substantial aluminum coarse focus controls which are based on standard rack and pinion in operation, these actuate on the stage not the limb. The fine focus system is 'sprung' to allow for wear take up and provides excellent 'feel' at all magnifications. The condenser is not 'quick release' like many microscopes although can be removed if required, the idea being you specified the desired condenser from Watson when ordering. They made a simple 2 element Abbe, 5 element achromatic shown [option of long working distance] and an oil immersion zonal dark field to be used with 90x or 100x objectives whose apertures have been reduced to NA of 1.0 using stops although this could be used for circular oblique illumination.

Watson say in their literature that the achromatic NA 0.9 is perfectly adequate for their oil immersion objectives. It is very well corrected for both spherical and chromatic aberrations. Small Allen key points set the centering of the phase annuli, [the phase outfit would originally have contained a small hex adjuster missing here], on this stand no adjustment was required. No filter tray is supplied with the achromatic condenser which prevents much experimentation with home made Rheinberg, circular oblique or other contrast techniques. Oblique illumination can be still applied by offsetting the brightfield port on the condenser, or movement of an opaque card say on the field lens and circular oblique on the 40x objective by using the 100x phase annuli whilst dark-field can be applied to the 10x objective using the same technique.


Phase outfit.



Phase outfit shown with 3 'Para' achromatic objectives. Positive and negative phase objectives were available.
Watson note that the phase plates are deposited on an optical element rather than use an additional glass plate.


A close up of the condenser and unassuming 'Para' phase objectives, a simple 'short' 5x 'Para' is also included in the set which is not shown here and on this sample needed an extending collar to make it roughly par-focal with the rest of the range. The phase range shown are 10x NA 0.28, 40x NA 0.70 and oil immersion 90x NA 1.30, the extra NA compared to many typical phase achromats provides a crisp clean look to phase with reduced 'shadowing' at the edges of prepared diatoms and little colour abnormalities.

The 7x compensating eyepieces should be used with objectives 20x and above and none compensating Huygenian below this, this is verified in taking photographs using a Sony P200. With the binocular head 1.5x factor this together with the supplied eyepieces gives 10x overall magnification. Watson did 'field' tests between parallel tube binocular and inclined binocular tubes asking how much strain the users had over continued use, the result was that most preferred the inclined so this was adopted.

The objective line up for the System 70 are 8 Parachromatic, 2 Planpara, 3 Fluorite and 3 Apochromatics with 7 phase variants so a good number to choose from. The Parachromatic 5x is reasonably plan whilst all of the phase objectives tested here give bright detailed images, my favourites being the 40x using circular oblique illumination [see later] with green or pale blue light and the 90x phase which gives excellent results. A total of 18 different eyepieces were available!



Phase bulb with light frosting.

The 6 volt 30 watt bulb comes in two types, clear and slightly frosted, the latter is designed for phase use where any filament abnormalities in the light path where reduced, my stand you can still see residual filament 'lines' in the field of view clearly picked up by camera, so only a partial success? This is as true to original Kohler you will find in any microscope and puts some modern research stands to shame pertaining to be of 'Kohler' design one of which I know has not one but two strong in line diffusers permanently in the light path.. however, the use of diffusers in the light path reflects the wide field of view eyepieces of today and small filament area of halogen bulbs compared to custom made tungsten bulbs and narrower field of view eyepieces of older designs.

The only diffusion is on the phase bulb and then if you order the clear version through the whole light path there are no diffusers. This has to be highly commended and shows how well Watson implemented the source illumination and condenser, it is pretty obvious the optics have been well chosen and researched. Remember there is no swing out element on the condenser only an auxiliary lens in the base for objectives above 20x. The ceramic bulb holder is pre-centered at the factory and collar on the bulb provides accurate centering within the holder, sadly on this one the solder had deteriorated and the collar had to be re-made. A rather fiddly metal plate holds the bulb securely in place acting against strong sprung bulb electrical contacts.


Inside the Kohler base.



Detail of Kohler base with cover removed.

A simple clean design in the base, the lever operated control on the left half way up is for the swing out auxiliary lens and in the center, the large drum operated by chord similar to design from 1960's transistor table radios is for the field iris, this has plenty of leaves although in use at high magnifications where the aperture is very small looks rather 'ragged' in the field of view. The large housing at the top holds the substantial mirror reflecting the light source up through the field lens attached on the top panel. All the metal work is substantial, well finished and simple in operation which should give many years of life. The Kohler base uses a total of 4 optical elements with the auxiliary lens in situ. The bulb is mounted in a bayonet fitting on the base back plate allowing easy bulb replacement without removing the base.

Other none Kohler variations are the mains voltage illumination base with 25 watt 100-120v or 200-250v ac diffused light and the low voltage base with 6v 18 watt bulb with rheostat built into the base.


The power supply.



Power supply with rheostat and meter.

The power unit normally rests via a large locating pin onto the top of the limb, I am not certain I like this but least it keeps all the parts together! It doesn't come much simpler with a rheostat and a rather quaint moving iron ac meter. The toggle switch for the 240 v ac mains can be seen on top together with the 3 way special socket to accept the mains, a rather inconvenient location I thought with the lead drooping down. The short thick cable seen at the top takes the variable low voltage to the bulb in the base. Laboratory instructions have been left on being part of its history! The unit is very easy to work on as shown below.




Detail of power supply with cover removed.

Underside of power supply, very simple operation with mains transformer feeding a good quality ceramic based rheostat with the meter indicating the working volts. This one had a modification to prevent operation above 6v by using a large wire wound resistor soldered in line with the rheostat to prevent bulbs being blown.. I guess by possible careless operators. This has been removed and restored to the original condition. Occasionally it is desirable to overdrive the bulb by a small percentage specially for high power phase. The rheostat turns were dirty as shown here causing fluctuations in light intensity but after a clean this was improved somewhat but not completely.



Mechanical stage.



Underside of bolt on stage controls.

This is the add on X Y control which can be retrofitted to plain stage with clips. It is attached by 3 large bolts with Allen key heads, although Watson describe this as an innovative design I came to dislike it with a passion when trying to refurbish it. As received the X control was lumpy and the Y control a rather frightening 'jump' to the right of objects occurred at anything above 10x. Whilst the rest of the microscope is well finished this didn't look up to the same standards being rather crude. It does prevent the typical protrusion you get from a rack and pinion design and I guess the wooden case gave Watson a 'headache' with its close fit when being brought down to be clipped to the base so the rack and pinion design was probably ruled out.

Here it shows the unit before being refurbished, it comes apart fairly easy, 2 screw heads can be seen on the horizontal X shaft these are the 'stops' to prevent too much travel. The mechanism relies on a friction coupled metal 'tape' running around a rotating rubber guide [hidden on the left] and the other end a 'sprung' rotating brass guide, seen above right, this gives the tension. The problem is the metal tape if removed has a tendency to twine itself in knots, is easily creased, flimsy and hard to work with. The friction if too loose between the brass X drive shaft and the rubber guide [there is no anchorage it is just a push on fit] leaves the X control stranded some where along its travel so any muck or oil that has creeped in could cause problems, I had to dismantle and clean. The springy copper alloy fingers holding the brass guide seen on the right above had to be re-tensioned which caused all sorts of problems. After spending hours of frustration I finally managed to get a working unit and all the work paid off with both the X and Y smooth in operation but for such a simple system it is very annoying to work on. I didn't dismantle the Y control working as best as I could cleaning parts in situ. Even this gave me a headache as there is control to set the angle of the slide carrier to prevent binding and scraping of the stage and is a combination of a metal plate with two screws and nylon adjustable grub screw but I got there in the end!


Some pictures.

A few images are shown below, the first, a crop of a human flea taken with the 5x objective using a hand held Sony P200 digital camera at the eyepiece.

The remaining three are two types of diatoms from a Klaus Kemp 8 form test plate [Stauroneis phoenocenteron and Navicula lyra] using a 1.3Mp Opticstar CCD camera in place of the eyepiece. Good detail and considering the Para's are not described as plan objectives give a competent flat field image. No additional sharpening has been applied post re-sizing.




Part of a human flea. 5x NA 0.12 Para objective.


40x NA 0.70 Para. Circular oblique using the 100x phase ring.
This is a powerful combination and ideal for e.g. diatom studies, utilising almost the full NA of the objective.


40x NA 0.70 Para. 50% oblique lighting using the offset brightfield port
in the phase condenser.


40x NA 0.70 Para. Circular oblique using the 100x phase ring, 'black dot' focus.


Conclusion.


I would say having used a number of other microscopes of several vintages over the years the Watson Microsystem 70 is on the whole very competent, although not the most elegant of microscopes it has on the plus side..

1. Cheap to buy and add to.
2. Good optics, quality achromatic phase condenser and objectives option being notable.
3. Excellent coarse and fine focus [at least on this stand], which should remain that way for years.
4. Good overall build and finish.
5. Relatively small footprint and tidy with the wooden case supplied.

Against, purely from personal operational preference is the sub stage height control, to a lesser degree the condenser iris adjustment and add on stage mechanics. Only 2 plan objectives are offered, 4x and 40x achromats so some photography will be limited although if parfocality is not an issue plan objectives from other makers could be used.

Comments to author are welcomed.

Resources and Acknowledgements

Further information is available on the series of 'Little Imp' CDs produced by Mike Samworth and Steve Gill; see the Savona Books U.K website. The 'Watson Microsystem 70' CD is 4, (Savona catalogue number M82). This provides a wealth of information on the Watson Microsystem 70 and Hilux 70 including brochures, original prices of the time, operation manuals, accessories, including phase, eyepieces and objective range, also a journal review of the microscope. There is little I could find on the Internet about the System 70 other than this excellent resource and Mike and Steve must be commended for assembling such useful information. The scans from the maker's literature in the article are from the CD and shared with thanks and permission from Mike Samworth and Steve Gill.

Little Imp have carefully compiled a wide range of CDs of often hard to source older literature on a wide variety of topics, including makers literature, papers and public domain books; for further details see the Savona Books website.

Once again Klaus Kemp's 'Test plate 8 forms' diatom slide proved to be an invaluable slide for setting up and using a microscope both visually and for imaging. This and his other slides are available from www.diatoms.co.uk

 

Microscopy UK FrontPage
Micscape Magazine
Article Library


Microscopy UK or their contributors.

Published in the December 2009 edition of Micscape Magazine.

Please report any Web problems or offer general comments to the Micscape Editor .

Micscape is the on-line monthly magazine of the Microscopy UK website at Microscopy-UK .  


Onview.net Ltd, Microscopy-UK, and all contributors 1995 onwards. All rights reserved. Main site is at www.microscopy-uk.org.uk .