AN ANNOTATED KEY FOR SPECIES OF THE FAMILY
"STENTORIDAE" and TWO RELATED FAMILIES

AN EXCURSION THROUGH THE TAXONOMIC MAZE

WALTER  DIONI                                          Durango (Dgo) Mexico
Printable version of keys extracted from and to be used in conjunction with the full two part article at:
http://www.microscopy-uk.org.uk/mag/artnov04/wdstentor.html
http://www.microscopy-uk.org.uk/mag/artnov04/wdstentor2.html

Prints out best in Microsoft Explorer 6.0.



Condylostomatidae
and Climacostomidae

are two families closely related to the Stentoridae. I want to propose a key for the reader to recognize the three families. Read carefully, because I include extended comments and some images between the various options.

 

The key is based on dichotomous selections. There are only two options, one is true, the other not. You compare your specimens with the options and decide which is in conformity with your material. The option gives you a denomination, or sends you to another dichotomous option.

Read the key as follows:


A(B) means that if option A is not true you must pass to the option B.
C at the end of the line means that if your material is in agreement with A you must continue to seek in the option C.


A(B) Peristomial bottom ciliated, without undulating membrane or with a rudimentary one ………….............................................................................................................................................................C

B (A) Body large, (700-900 microns) contractile; with one undulating membrane very visible on the right* anterior end; one Adoral Zone of Membranelles (AZM) delimits a peristomial bottom without cilia ................................................................................................................................. CONDYLOSTOMATIDAE

                     

            With one vast peristome, V shaped; macronucleus moniliform                                              …………………………......................................................................... Condylostoma Bory de St. Vincent, 1824

 

Some species of Condylostoma can be seen at
HTTP://protist.ihosei.ac.jp/PDB/Images/Ciliophora/Condylostoma/index.HTML


Stentor auriculatus
was included in Condylostoma as C. auriculata, since it has the characteristics of the family and the genus (undulating membrane, V shaped peristome, peristomial bottom without cilia, moniliform nucleus.), (Fauré-Fremiet 1936).

Note: Kahl presents and illustrates moreover S. auricula Kent 1881. In the illustrations of Kahl, both species are fixed at the substrate, showing the stentor's aspect. Other species of Condylostoma are free, and the only image which we can ascribe to C. auriculata (a picture taken by Jean Marie Cavanihac from the Mediterranean shore, see it below) shows a free individual.

S. auricula according to Fauré-Fremiet 1936, and Foissner and Wölfl 1994 is most probably a species of Condylostoma, however Kahl allots a single and oval nucleus to it. Obviously this species (if it exists) needs to be newly found and well described. It was found only in 1881 among bryozoa in the aquarium at Westminter.


It is a notable fact that these two species (at least in the documents that I could find on the Internet) "disappeared", being quoted neither as Stentor, nor as Condylostentor, nor as Condylostoma.


C(D) Large body, generally with ovoid shape with a truncated former end. More or less flat body; a large and visible AZM, in the left edge* of the peristome, spiralling into cytostome, uniform somatic cilia. A contractile posterior vacuole ………............................................................................................................................CLIMACOSTOMIDAE

 

Included here is Fabrea Henneguy 1910, a genus found in brackish water (up to 20% of salinity), often found in saltworks, and Climacostomum, Stein 1859, from fresh and brackish waters. Species of the two genera are relatively small (around 300 microns).

Image of Fabrea salina HTTP ://power.ib.pi.CNR.it/groups/fabrea/ottico.HTML
Image of Climacostomum
httm//mtlab.biol.tsukuba.ac.jp/www/PDB/Images/Ciliophora/Climacostomum/sp_1.jpg


D(C) Form of long reversed cone (shaped as a "trumpet") adhesive posterior end, with one Adoral Zone of Membranelles forming a spiral around one vast and ciliated peristomial bottom. Anterior contractile vacuole, with thin channels, one with the length of the cell and another around the base of the peristome
.........………...................................................................................................................STENTORIDAE

 

* To understand the orientation of a subject in a drawing or a picture, it is necessary to consider how it is presented with respect to the observer. On this assumption, what is at our left in the drawing or photograph, corresponds to the right in the organism. If no special statement is made it is assumed that the organism is drawn by the ventral face.




Preparing now the key of the Stentoridae family, I allow myself some freedom for the benefit of the amateur microscopist, such as including without ambiguity the genus Parastentor * within the family.

As I say below I do not have any data for the species Stentoropsis, so I do not include it.
Moreover for the reasons which I give below I consider it premature to include Heterostentor.

* Parastentor is an interesting European species, which needs confirmation, and which perhaps could be found and be redefined by some microscopist out of its standard locality in a Hungarian lake.


 

SUMMARY OF THE FAMILY STENTORIDAE

 
List of genera and its type species
(generally this is the first species assigned to the genus)

 

Genus Stentor Oken, 1815
        Type species Stentor muelleri (Bory of St. Vincent, 1824) Ehrenberg, 1831


Genus Maristentor, Lobban et al. 2002
        Type species Maristentor dinoferus Lobban et al. 2002
 

Incertae sedis (genera or species for which there are doubts about its correct situation for lack of adequate data,)
 
Dennys Lynn in her taxonomic list (to genus inclusively) considers the following genera of doubtful position in the family:

Genus Stentoropsis Dogiel and Bychowsky 1934,
         Type species: S. barbi Dogiel and Bychowsky 1934
(I could not find neither a description nor a bibliographical quotation for this genus and species, accepted as good by J. O. Corliss 1961 and by D. Lynn 2002. It does not appear in any of the consulted papers nor in any of the specialized sites on the Web. Almost certainly the article which describes it is written in German. Having no data on this species I could not include it in the key of genera.)

Genus Parastentor Vuxanovici 1961,
Type species P. tentaculatus Vuxanovici 1961,

The species has two retractile side tentacles covered in longer cilia than those of the body. It was observed twice, in a Hungarian Lake.

 
Genus Heterostentor, Song and Wilbert 2002
Type species: Heterostentor coeruleus Song and Wilbert, 2002
Only one species known, with intense blue pigment, and observed in the Antarctic Ocean.

Situation of Heterostentor

In reality Heterostentor resembles less of the features of Stentoridae than Condylostoma auriculata does. Its only character of Stentoridae is to have a peristomial bottom surrounded by a AZM similar to that of Stentor, without undulating membrane, and the ectodermic blue pigment. Its form is that of an ellipsoid very widened with one anterior contraction where the AZM is placed, and without adhesive foot. It is described without symbiotic algae, without cytopharynx or visible cytostome and its small peristomial bottom does not have cilia on its surface. It is a free living protozoon never adhering to substrate as Stentor, Maristentor, Parastentor and surely Stentoropsis  does. In my opinion so many differences would justify to separate it into a different family which would have to be named Heterostentoridae.

Although I give this description and its iconography, I do not include it in the key.





LIST OF VALID SPECIES OF THE GENUS STENTOR
Arranged according to the date of its first description


01

St. polymorphus

(O F. Müller, 1773) Ehrenberg, 1838

Cosmopolitan

02

St. Niger

(OF. Müller, 1773) Ehrenberg 1831

Europe

03

St. multiformis

(O F. Mueller, 1786) Ehrenberg 1838

Marine populations? Cosmopolitan?

04

St. muelleri

(Bory St. Vincent, 1824) Ehrenberg, 1838

Cosmopolitan **

05

St. coeruleus

Ehrenberg, 1830

Cosmopolitan **

06

St. roeselii

Ehrenberg, 1835

Cosmopolitan **

07

St. igneus

Ehrenberg, 1838

Cosmopolitan

08

St. barretti

Barrett 1870

Europe

09

St. elegans

Fromentel 1876

Central and Eastern Europe **

10

St. amethystinus

Leidy, 1880

Cosmopolitan? **

11

St. fuliginosus

Forbes 1891

Cosmopolitan?

12

St. pyriformis

Johnson, 1893

North America and Mexico

13

St. baicalius

(Swarczewsky 1929) Foissner 1994

Lake Baikal

14

St. loricatus

Barry 1950

News Zealand

15

St. introversus

Tartar, 1958

North America

16

St. caudatus

Dragesco 1970

Africa

17

St. multimicronucleatus

Dragesco 1970

Tropical Africa

18

St. katashimai

Kumazawa 1973

Japan

19

St. tartari

Narayana Murthy and Kasturi Bai 1974

described from Bangalore (India), and Kenya (Africa)

20

St. araucanus

Foissner and Wölfl 1994

Andean lakes of southern South America

21

St. cornutus

Kumazawa, 2002

Japan

** The species marked by 2 asterisks are illustrated in the key.




IDENTIFICATION KEY

Abbreviations: Mn - macronucleus, Mic. - micronucleus, µ - microns, AZM Adoral Zone of Membranelles

For a more convenient (and different) presentation, we will use here numbers instead of letters.

1 (2) Marine species. Shaped as very wide trumpets, with a vast peristomial bottom abruptly widened. Peristome divided by one deep central notch, which makes it appear bilobate. With many bands of cortical pigment and abundant zooxanthella (symbiotic algae derived from dinoflagelates). With many cilia dispersed in the vast peristomial bottom. AZM similar to that of Stentor Maristentor

Only one species with a rounded macronucleus located close to the anterior end. Has a length of a around 900 microns. It was identified until now only on the island of Guam. M. dinoferus Lobban and all, 2002
2(1) freshwater species 3
3(4) with retractile and ciliated side tentacles Parastentor

only one species (Hungary)
P. tentaculatus Vuxanovichi (1961)
4(3) with circular or reniforme peristome. Cilia of the peristomial bottom laid out in regular lines which follow the contour of the peristome. Body covered with longitudinal lines of cilia, which can contain Stereocils ("rigid sensory hairs") of a size larger than the cilia, with intermediate ectoplasmic bands and pigmented granules or not. Without side tentacles



5
5
we have arrived at the genus Stentor go to 6

The genus is known by the majority of microscopists, the most frequent species, which normally have an average size (from 1 to 1.5 mm) have the definite shape of a widened "trumpet". However some species of the genus vary a lot, and there are some conical, short forms (less than 200 microns), with a very wide peristomial bottom, which gives them the shape of a reversed bell. When contracted all the forms adopt an ovoid or pear shaped aspect, truncated by the AZM in the anterior end.

The number of lines of cilia of the peristomial bottom, like those of the body, is an important secondary specific character. Some species of Stentor can have symbiotic algae called zoochlorelles.

After this first basic dichotomy, the following options require more space to continue with a rigorous description of only two options. Thus, and having shown to the beginners the principle of a dichotomous taxonomic key, to save space I give up it for a simple table with multiple choices and very easy to follow.


6 (7) With zoochlorelles

a) Nucleus vermiforme, blue pigment...............................................................
araucanus

b) Nucleus moniliform........................................................................................
polymorphus

c) Nucleus multiglobular....................................................................................



c1) 2 or 3 Mn, red pigment
(the population must be searched with care because of the possibility of the subject being a rare multiglobular specimen of St. fuliginosus)


tartari

c2) 2 (still 5) macronucleus. Colourless.......................................................
pyriformis

d) One single and globular macronucleus



d.1 Pigment crimson, which can appear brown or even black, by effect of the zoochlorelles. Mic. surrounded by pigment granules (see fuliginosus).................................................................................................


amethystinus

d.2 maroon pigment or reddish. Mic. not surrounded by granules of pigment (see amethystinus)........................................................................

fuliginosus

According to Foissner and Wölfl, 1994. It could be a synonym of amethistinum. In the two species the combination of zoochlorelles with the pigment tends to mask the color, which appears almost black.


7 (6) Without zoochlorelles

a) Nucleus vermiform 


a1) colourless*, a gelatinous lorica.........................................................
roeselii

a2) green pigment, with lorica.................................................................
loricatus

b) Nucleus nodular, peristomial bottom bilobate, long and thin cytoplasmic filament connecting it to the substratum, with lorica.......................................
barretti

c) Nucleus moniliform



c1) bluish color



c1.1) With buccal pouch..........................................................................
coeruleus

c1.2) Without buccal pouch, retractile peristomial edge.......................
introversus

(in specimens retracted of introversus, the peristomial edge form one large pad around the peristomial bottom, assimilating almost completely the AZM)



c2) colourless


c2.1) Without lorica



c2.1.1) Without buccal pouch



30-42 segments in Mn. Short and squat in the shape of a bell with a lengthened foot........................................................................


caudatus

7-18 segments in Mn, in the shape of long trumpet..................................................................

cornutus

c2.12) With buccal pouch; small and regularly conical.............................................................................


katashimai

c2.2) With lorica, without pouch, very long and thin, with long and rigid stereocils in regular groups.......................................................................................


muelleri

d) Multiglobular nucleus (4 globules), without zoochlorelles, bluish............................................................................................................
baicalius

e) Single globular nucleus



e1) Colourless *



Macronucleus 40-62 µ, 52-142 Mic..............................
multimicronucleatus

One oval Macronucleus <40 µ......................................
elegans

NOTE: * Colourless : they can be transparent, but according to their size and the opacity of the cytoplasm they can appear yellowish, but their ectoplasmic granules are not pigmented.







e2) Coloured



Shades of red........................................................
igneus

Blue, with a small lorica.......................................
multiformis

Dark coffee...........................................................
niger




REFERENCES

Colin, Christian, 2003: Mon Stentor-demon .Magazine MicrOscOpies on - line

CORLISS, John O., 1961: The Ciliate Protozoa. 310 pgs. XXII plates. Pergamon Press

FOISSNER W. & WÖLFL S., 1994: Revision of the genus Stentor OKEN (Protozoa, Ciliophora) and description of S. araucanus Nov.. spec. from South American lakes. – Journal of Plankton Research - Vol.16 - pp. 255-289.

KAHL, A., 1935.- Wimpertiere oder ciliata.
on line:
HTTP://ameba.Ihosei.ac.jp/DIB/Kahl/

KUMAZAWA H, 2002.- Notes on the taxonomy of Stentor Oken (Protozoa, Ciliophora) and a description of a new species. Journal of Plankton Research – Vol. 24 No.1 - pp. 69-75

LOBBAN, C.S., SCHEFTER, M, SIMPSON, A.G.B., LADLE, X., PAWLOWSKI, J., AND FOISSNER, W., 2002 - Maristentor dinoferus N. gen., N. sp., a giant heterotrich ciliate (Spirotrichea: Heterotrichida) with zooxanthellae, from coral reefs of Guam, Marian Islands. –Marine Biology, 2002. Vol. 140: pp 411-423
HTTP://www.uog.edu/dns/Maristentor_article.Pdf

DENNIS H. LYNN (on line, unpublished) June 14, 2002 - Classification of the Phylum Ciliophora
HTTP://www.uoguelph.will ca/~ciliates/classification/genera.HTML

For the most recent, published revision by D.H. Lynn see:
LYNN, D.H. AND E.B. SMALL. 1997 Revised Classification of the Phylum Ciliophora Doflein, 1901. Rev. Soc. Mex. Hist. Nat. Vol.47: pp 65-78.

SONG, Weibo and WILBERT, Norbert. 2002 - Faunistic Studies on Marine Ciliates from the Antarctic Benthic Area, Including Descriptions of One Epizoic Form, 6 New Species, and 2 New Genera (Protozoa: Ciliophora) Acta Protozool. Vol.41: 23 - 61.
HTTP://www.nencki.gov.pl/pdf/ap/ap583.pdf

Fauré-Fremiet, et. 1936 - Condylostoma (Stentor) auriculatus (Gruber) Bull. Soc. Zool. France 61: 511-519.

(I was able to consult this last work by courtesy of Prof. Daniel Nardin.)

Acknowledgements

I thank in particular Doctor Foissner and Doctor Kumazawa, who made possible this article by kindly sending their papers to me, and to all those authors who liberally shared their research on the Web. And especially to Domenique Voisin and Jean Marie Cavanihac, who allowed the free use of their pictures to illustrate this article. It is at the same time a Homage to Christian Colin, and a recognition of the important labour of research and documentation made in the past few years by the participants in the French Forums of Microscopy.



Comments to the author, Walter Dioni at wdioni2002dATyahooDOTcom are welcomed.
Change capitals to email format and paste into email software.


 

Microscopy UK Front Page
Micscape Magazine
Article Library


© Microscopy UK or their contributors. Published in the November 2004 edition of Micscape.
Please report any Web problems or offer general comments to the Micscape Editor.

Micscape is the on-line monthly magazine of the Microscopy UK web
site at Microscopy-UK

© Onview.net Ltd, Microscopy-UK, and all contributors 1995 onwards. All rights reserved. Main site is at www.microscopy-uk.org.uk with full mirror at www.microscopy-uk.net.